IDP Sleepers and Busts
|
Posted 9/5 by the IDP Staff, Exclusive to Footballguys.com
|
DALLAS COWBOYS
By David Baker
Sleeper: Dat Nguyen (5'11" 243) was the third round pick for Dallas
in 1999. After a big year in 2001, many IDP loyalists expected even bigger things
from him in 2002. An injury in 2002 limited Dat to about half the season, but
he rebounded nicely in 2003 for 88 tackles, 31 assists and a pair of sacks.
He even had 11 passes defended and 2 forced fumbles. In many leagues, his numbers
were top 20 stuff. There was even some talk of him making the Pro Bowl. However,
as he enters the peak years of his career, Nguyen sometimes gets little attention
in IDP drafts. Nguyen is a three down linebacker, something you see less and
less of in the NFL these days. Although he might not be the biggest and tallest
LB out there, he's smart and instinctive. He religiously studies game film to
put him in the right spot to make plays and has proven to be very effective
against the run. Even his coverage skills have greatly improved. The only mark
on him has been an inability to stay on the field, as Nguyen has twice missed
significant time during a season due to injuries. Although Head Coach Bill Parcells
has a reputation for liking bigger LB's, his affection for Nguyen has been prominent.
Look for Dat Nguyen to have a career year in that increasingly effective Dallas
defense.
Bust: Darren Woodson (6'1" 219) is old by NFL standards. He's now
35. He was a 2nd round pick by Dallas way back in 1992. He's coming off another
solid season with 65 tackles and 20 assists with a sack and INT to boot. But
he's lost a step and does not match up well anymore with the faster receivers
coming out of the slot. He's already admitted this might be his final season.
Then, a couple of weeks ago Woodson had surgery to remove a herniated disk.
He's scheduled to be sidelined 6-8 weeks, which means he at the very least misses
the season opener. In an attempt to come back quicker, Woodson overworked himself
and needed an epidural to alleviate the pain. Although Woodson is attempting
to return earlier, the doctors believe a more likely scenario is for him to
return by game 3. Although his courage is admirable, along with his distinguished
career, all signs do not point to a recipe for FF success this year. Avoid him.
NEW YORK GIANTS
By David Baker
Sleeper: Shaun Williams (6'1" 218) joined the NY Giants after being
drafted in the first round in 1998. He seemed meant to be a Giant. He was even
born the same exact day Giants Stadium opened. Needless to say there was a lot
expected from him. For the most part, Williams has fulfilled those expectations.
The main problem for Williams has been staying on the field. He missed parts
of his first two seasons. He then had solid seasons from 2000 to 2002, averaging
over 70 tackles and 20 assists per year during that period. Despite some solid
years, Williams never quite reached that elite level projected by him by those
in the NY staff that drafted him. Last year was perhaps Williams roughest year.
He generally played poorly, making coverage mistakes, and then missed the last
6 games due to a knee injury. But he has worked on those aspects with the coaching
staff and is now healthy and 100%. Williams is known for his punishing hits
and excels in run support. The Giants have put in a new defensive system that
should reduce his coverage mistakes and help him understand his responsibilities.
Shaun Williams weighs less than he has since college. The lighter weight helped
Williams rehab from knee surgery and he's apparently quicker. His new coaches
have been pleased with his ability to pick up the defense.
Bust: Many thought Nick Greisen (6'1" 245) had the lead for becoming
the starting MLB for the Giants on opening day. Greisen, who just recently turned
25 years old, was the Giants 5th round pick in 2002. His two-year NFL career
consists of 23 total games, 10 tackles, 6 assists and 1 sack. Most of his playing
time to date has been on special teams. Those aren't exactly the numbers you're
looking for to become the starting MLB. Despite that, when the Giants cut Mike
Barrow last March 10 in a salary cap maneuver, the starting MLB position was
thrust upon Greisen. All looked well for the young Greisen, who was working
extra hard to be the man on opening day. Then, the former Wisconsin star suddenly
was hit with a hamstring injury and his already shaky stranglehold on the position
took a dip for the worse. On the second play of his first preseason game as
starter, Greisen dropped back in coverage and strained his left hamstring. The
perception at the Giants camp was that Greisen needed a strong camp to show
he could handle his new promotion. The injury might only keep him out for a
week, but Greisen needed all the playing time possible to retain the job. Unproven
Quincy Monk no suddenly appears in the picture. Head Coach Tom Coughlin is not
known for his tolerance of injured players. For me, there's too much risk in
drafting Greisen now.
PHILADELPHIA EAGLES
By David Baker
Sleeper: Michael Lewis (6'1" 211) is just coming into his own.
The talented second round pick in 2002 became the starter the last four games
his rookie season and hasn't looked back. Frankly, if it weren't for a heart
condition, Lewis likely would have been a first round choice. In 2003, Lewis
ended up with 65 tackles, 20 assists, 2 sacks and 3 INTs Lewis was forced to
mature quickly in 2003, as he witnessed his fellow Eagle DBs get hurt right
and left. At various times last year, Brian Dawkins, Bobby Taylor and Troy Vincent
all missed time due to injuries. Defensive Coordinator Jim Johnson relied on
Lewis to be their signal caller. Lewis did not disappoint. The secondary came
to be known by Head Coach Andy Reid as "Michael Lewis and the no-names."
Lewis continued to show he was a big hitter and a playmaker. Lewis' aggressive
play combined with his intelligence helped him emerge as the leader of their
secondary, despite his very soft-spoke nature. There's talk now that the tandem
of Lewis with FS Brian Dawkins could be the best duo in franchise history. You
won't go wrong taking Michael Lewis on your FF roster.
Bust: Since acquiring former All-Pro Jeremiah Trotter in the offseason,
many believe the writing is on the wall for Mark Simoneau. Simoneau (6'0"
234), a four year NFL vet drafted by Atlanta in the 3rd round of the 2000 draft,
had a nice year for Philly in 2003. "Frenchy", as he is known by his
fellow Eagle LB's, led the Eagles in 2003 with 78 tackles and 22 assists. What
he lacks in size he makes up in speed. Simoneau, though, seemed to struggle
a bit as the season wore on. The Eagles gave up too many rushing yards, and
Simoneau was at least partly to blame for that. In the offseason, he added some
extra weight and hoped it would not affect his speed or quickness. I think the
opposite could occur and with Trotter breathing down his neck, the lost speed
and quickness could mean the difference in Simoneau losing his starting job.
And despite attempts to state otherwise, DC Jim Johnson's statements do not
sound like ringing endorsements. He stated recently, "
Mark Simoneau
is our middle linebacker
I want everyone to realize that I think Mark Simoneau
is a heck of a football player, and I am not going to change my mind because
we signed Jeremiah
Now, things might happen, but Mark Simoneau is our middle
linebacker
" Then, a little later, Johnson said, "A lot of things
can happen. It's a long season. A month from now, maybe things are different.
Who knows?" And after Trotter, who has a big edge in the physical part
of the game, dominated the action in live goal line drills, Johnson stated,
"He looked like the Trotter that I knew, as far as attacking things, blowing
things up." So while I wouldn't give up on Simoneau quite yet, it's a big
risk to take him in FF. It could just be a matter of time before Trotter takes
over for him.
WASHINGTON REDSKINS
By David Baker
Sleeper: Mike Barrow (6'1" 245) is what you would call an NFL vet.
The 34 year old was drafted way back in 1993 in the second round by the then
Houston Oilers. He's also played for Carolina, the New York Giants and now the
Skins. Through it all, he's only missed five games. He's registered 800 career
tackles, 333 assists and 43 sacks. He's had a lot of very good seasons with
every team he's played for. As a tackle producer, though, 2003 was his best
season yet. He had 109 tackles, 39 assists and a pair of sacks. A monster year
by any measure. In the offseason, the Giants elected to do a complete overhaul
of their linebackers, much to the good fortune of the Redskins, who replaced
Jeremiah Trotter on their roster with Barrow. Much of Barrow's tremendous success
can be attributed to his incredible work ethic. After his first Skins minicamp,
as most players dragged their way off the field and into the showers, Barrow
instead went to the weight room where he started up on the treadmill. So while
some may think of Barrow as an old man on the downside of his career, I would
not assume so much quite yet. MLB this year for the Skins should present an
excellent opportunity for Barrow to continue his tackle domination in the NFL.
Bust: Phillip Daniels (6'5" 285) is the starting RDE for the Skins.
He will be counted on to provide a pass rushing attack from their line. Since
being drafted in the 4th round in 1996 by Seattle, Daniels has proven to be
a solid NFL end. He played four seasons with the Seahawks followed by four more
with the Bears. Twice, Daniels has had 9 sacks in a season. He has 44.5 sacks
in his career and has been solid in run support. However, last year Daniels
only had 2.5 sacks, his fewest since his rookie campaign. Recently, Daniels
has been bothered by an abdominal strain. At first, he was listed as out indefinitely
and then day-to-day. He is now back practicing. But at 31, having never been
a pass rushing monster to begin with, playing on a new team and facing injury
question marks, I would suggest passing on Phillip Daniels this year.
CHICAGO BEARS
By David Baker
Deeeep Sleeper: Marcus Reese (6'1" 233), an undrafted LB out of
UCLA, was picked up by the Chicago Bears last November after being released
by the 49ers. This spring, Reese spent some time in NFL Europe playing for the
Cologne Centurions. After his return from Europe, Reese proceeded to turn heads
during Bears workouts. At UCLA, Reese played a similar defensive system as the
Bears, and his talents fit nicely. Known for his athleticism, quickness and
speed, Reese is now in a decent position to win the SLB position, now currently
occupied by Bryan Knight and/or Joe Odom on the depth charts. Reese is so athletic
that he lined up at safety in some practices, a position he played when he was
younger. With a productive training camp, Reese could find himself going from
NFL Europe to starting LB for the Chicago Bears.
Sleeper: Lance Briggs- Briggs (6'1" 245), the Bears 3rd round draft
pick in 2003 worked his way into the starting lineup last year, and despite
only 13 starts Briggs finished with over 60 tackles and 13 assists. Briggs is
extremely athletic with good speed and is a relentless heavy hitter. With Brian
Urlacher recently going down with injury, Chicago has moved Briggs to the middle
to see how he reacts. Briggs won the starting job at SLB and showed the speed
and explosiveness to move to the weakside this year. Briggs is a sure tackler
whose only area of weakness is in coverage. With his abilities and playing WLB
in Lovie Smith's defensive scheme, Briggs should enjoy a big year and make his
FF owners very happy.
Bust: Michael Haynes, the Bears 1st round pick, and the 14th pick overall
in the 2003 draft, was hoped to be the savior on the Bears defensive line. At
this point with the 6'4, 281 DE, the jury is still out. Haynes likely replaces
Philip Daniels in the starting lineup and he brings some solid speed and closing
burst with him. But some observers are now wondering whether he has the strength,
quickness and athletic ability to turn the corner on the pass rush. Some hint
at his lack of instinctiveness. Fortunately for Haynes, there is not much competition
behind him. To me, Haynes is too risky a pick at DE and I'd prefer to look elsewhere.
DETROIT LIONS
By David Baker
Sleeper: Kalimba Edwards (6'5" 264) had everything going for home
as he came to the Lions with the 35th overall in the 2nd round in 2002. Edwards
is a lightning quick pure pass-rushing end that is blessed with incredible athleticism.
Thus far in his short NFL career, though, Edwards has always seemed to be hampered
by nagging injuries. His rookie season showed just enough promise to leave the
Lion's fans salivating. In limited, situational playing time, Edwards ended
up with about 30 tackles and 6.5 sacks. Last year, though, was a nightmare for
Edwards. His injuries severely limited his playing time and he ended up with
terrible numbers. In the offseason, he had sports hernia surgery. Now, Edwards
is apparently feeling better than ever. His groin injury is a thing of the past.
Look for 2004 to be Edwards breakout year and for him to get double digit sacks.
Bust: SS Brian Walker (6'2" 205) was an undrafted player when he
came into the league in 1997, but he has proven to be a solid vet. Known for
good instincts and field awareness, Walker was part of a top ranked Dolphins
defense in 2000 and 2001. In 2003, he had one of his most productive NFL seasons
with 65 tackles and 20 assists. Although not exactly a FF star, Walker's numbers
were respectable. This year, Detroit is moving him to the strong safety position,
a situation where usually an IDP's numbers thrive. However, with Walker, I would
not jump on that bandwagon too soon. Aside from struggling in man to man coverage,
Walker is not a great tackler and is poor in run support. With Terrance Holt
waiting in the wings to play somewhere at safety, Walker does not appear to
be the ideal solution for the Lions at this point of his career. Once a solid
football player, Walker is now 32 and should be avoided in IDP drafts.
GREEN BAY
By David Baker
Sleeper: Na'il Diggs (6'4" 237), whose first name is Arabic and
translates to "successful one", has seen his tackle numbers grow in
each of his four years in the NFL, and he ended up with 76 tackles and 11 assists
last year. All this despite an injury plagued season in 2003. A 4th round pick
by Green Bay in 2000, Diggs has now made 50 consecutive starts over three seasons,
the most by any Packer since John Anderson in the mid-80's. Diggs has moved
from the strong side to the weak side this year, replacing Nate Wayne, in hopes
of exploiting his closing speed and tackling ability. The positional switch
alone is often a predictor of increased FF success. Expect Diggs to be given
more opportunities to blitz this season and expect a career high in tackles.
This should be a big year for Diggs.
Bust: Nick Barnett. That's right, you read that correctly. I predict
Nick Barnett as my bust on the Green Bay defense for FF. Barnett (6'2"
233), the much heralded first round pick for Green Bay in 2003 had a remarkable
rookie campaign, by nearly all accounts. He ended the season with 86 tackles,
26 assists, 2 sacks and 3 INTs He plays with reckless abandon. He was named
the 2003 Packers Defensive Player of the Year. He was the first rookie to start
at Middle Linebacker since Mike Hunt in 1978. Barnett is so athletic, he actually
played safety in college until moving to linebacker in his sophomore year. He
finished 3rd in the AP voting for defensive rookie of the year. He lad all NFL
rookies in tackles. His intelligence and sideline to sideline speed has helped
him overcome his lack of size. So then why would I possibly label him a bust???
Although he's still young, I think play action fakes too often dupe Barnett
and he sometimes loses sight of his assignments. But mainly, the reason I predict
Barnett to be a bust is not so much that I think his numbers are disastrous,
but because I think he will be overvalued by others. In my opinion, his numbers
will actually decrease from last year. Why? In part because I believe that Diggs
increased play over Wayne at WLB will take some tackles away from Barnett, and
in part because it's just plain tough to meet the success he enjoyed as a rookie.
Sophomore jinx? Maybe not as an NFL player, but in FF terms, I think IDP owners
should be very wary about drafting him too highly.
MINNESOTA VIKINGS
By David Baker
Sleeper: Chris Hovan was a highly regarded DT coming out as the 25th
pick overall coming out in the 2001 NFL draft. At 6'2"/296, Hovan has a
tremendous work ethic, incredible quickness and can really get to the QB for
a DT. In 2001, Hovan had 6 sacks and followed that up with 5.5 in 2002. In 2002
Hovan also had 38 tackles and 14 assists as he truly came into his own. Because
of his successes, in 2003 Hovan became the recipient of constant double teams.
For Minnesota coaches, this was a welcome thing as the double teams allowed
his Viking teammates more room to go after the ball. For IDP Hovan owners, though,
2003 was a bust. His tackle numbers plummeted and he registered only two sacks.
Although Hovan tried to keep upbeat, the expectations from his previous seasons
sometimes got to him.
In 2004, however, look for Hovan to get his production back up. He lost about
10 pounds in the offseason and looks quicker than ever. Hovan worked out in
the offseason with Junior Seau and claims to be in the best shape of his career.
He has concentrated his offseason in working on his flexibility and spicing
up his pass rushing techniques. Hovan has also been working with DL coach Brian
Baker to camouflage his pre-snap position and expand his array of pass-rush
moves. Hovan's counterpart, second year player Kevin Williams, is just coming
into his own. Also a first round draft pick, Williams presence should greatly
reduce the number of double teams Hovan faces. And rookie DE Kenechi Udeze makes
the Viking defensive line that much more formidable. With so many players to
stop now and with defenses having to worry so much about Kevin Williams, look
for Chris Hovan to have a big FF year and approach 10 sacks. Not too shabby
for your DT.
Bust: Brian Russell is a talented young safety for the Vikings. He came
out of San Diego St undrafted in 2001. Russell came on very strong last year
for Minnesota, garnering 78 tackles, 17 assists and 9 INTs His 9 INTs led the
league. It was the kind of season many IDP hounds look for on the waiver wire
and indeed Russell was top 10 in many IDP leagues amongst fellow DBs Included
in his 9 INTs was one streak at the start of the season where he had an INT
over six straight games, tying a Viking record shared with the legendary Paul
Krause. Despite all of this, the Vikings only signed Russell to a minimum contract
for a two year vet. Apparently, the Vikings are not completely sold on Russell,
whom they say is not as solid as need be at open-field tackling. One Viking
staffer pointed out that Russell got a lot of INTs on tipped balls and overthrows.
Minnesota is now said to be looking towards third year player Willie Offord
to take Russell's job. And as we know in FF, it's all about opportunity. Russell
is not about to give up on his spot yet, and he currently remains the Viking
starter at FS. But the writing is on the wall. Picking Russell on your fantasy
squad has bust written all over it, if only because he might be replaced as
the starter.
ATLANTA FALCONS
By Bob Magaw
Sleeper: Chris Draft (5'11" 232)... rang up 105 solo tackles last
season from WLB. This was good for the tenth highest tackle total in the NFL,
just after Keith Bullock's (TEN) breakout season, and ahead of stud interior
LBs James Farrior (PIT), Jay Foreman (HOU) and London Fletcher (BUF). He slides
over to MLB in a position switch with new WLB Keith Brooking (126 solos last
season from the middle) after an offseason minicamp experiment was greenlighted
by the Falcon's new HC Jim Mora, Jr. and DC Donatell. With opposing O-Lines
having to concern themselves with the problematic speed and quickness of interior
rushing presence Rod Coleman, the prized free agent acquisition from the Raiders,
as well as a more attacking scheme up front (using a 4-3 base formation which
better plays to the strengths of their edge rushing DE's), Draft could conceivably
see an increase in production this season. Brooking's 126 solo tackles from
that position in '03 tied for the league lead with Donnie Edwards (SD), and
even surpassed tackle machines Ray Lewis (BAL) and Jamie Sharper (HOU), who
finished with 125 and 124 solo tackles, respectively. If something remotely
like this scenario transpires, he will significantly outperform his ADP value.
There is a slight concern in some quarters that Jamie Duncan, the journeyman
ex-Buc and, most recently, Ram MLB/roadkill, could contend for Draft's job.
To Ram fans who have to dredge up the painful memories of the past two forgettable
years seeing him stomped like an old drunk, in way over his head at the running
of the bulls in Pamplona, Spain, that evokes only one possible incredulous response...
BWAHAHAHAHAHAHA! For those on the doomed Duncan watch, on the fractional chance
that he wins the job, there is a shred of consolation in the fact that the Falcon
defense was statistically among the worst in the league by some measures, and
Draft was a big part of that (backhanded compliment). There is a small but insistent
body of skepticism on the part of some scouts and Falcon insiders that underscores
the troubling tendency for too many of Draft's tackles being made downfield,
and rumblings that he may not be MLB material... so read to the end of the brochure
when considering him.
Bust: DeAngelo Hall (5'10" 197)... the eighth selection overall
in the '03 draft, the second defensive player and DB and top CB taken, some
in leagues distinguishing between safeties and CBs will be tempted by his reputation
as one of the fastest players in the draft. The former Virginia Tech teammate
of Michael Vick was one of the only football players in the country that could
best the rocket-fueled lefty in a foot race. He is an amazing athlete who helped
lead his team to a state championship his senior year in high school by scoring
30 touchdowns and rushing for over 1,300 yards, also finishing sixth nationally
in the 60-meter dash as a junior, and third in the state long jump as a senior.
He has probable Darrell Green-like make up speed, though he doesn't possess
the world class aerial skills and ability to break on the ball of FS prodigy
Sean Taylor (WAS). With veteran Jason Webster imported from the 49ers by Mora
and now slated to play opposite Hall, the rookie can expect to be tested and
picked on until he plays well enough to discourage opposing offensive coordinators
and QBs from sending the ball in his direction. But with rare exceptions, INTs
tend to be hit and miss and CB totals in that statistic fluctuate wildly from
season to season. The most consistent source of scoring for almost all IDP positions
is tackles (some elite DEs are money in the bank by furnishing consistent sack
totals... see Strahan, Rice, Taylor, Little and Grant). While Hall seems more
than willing to mix it up in run support, he is not as accomplished or refined
in that skill as Dunta Robinson (HOU), the tenth overall selection in the '03
draft and second CB taken off the board. Robinson is the smart play to lead
all rookie CBs best positioned to start this season in the tackle column. The
man who is having a bad hair life, Mel Kiper, called him one of the surest and
most formidable open field tacklers for a CB in the past decade.
CAROLINA PANTHERS
By Bob Magaw
Sleeper: Dan Morgan (6'2" 233)... To generalize Churchill's cryptic
quotation on Russia, Morgan is a sleeper wrapped in a bust inside a gamble.
When healthy, he is the complete package, with athleticism, strength, speed,
suddenness, instincts, intensity and a bad disposition towards the offensive
side of the ball... perhaps only his size is sub-optimal (one of the lighter
MLBs in the game), but he compensates with explosiveness. The former first rounder
(1.11 '01) has the natural talent, ability and skills to be one of the top 5-10
LBs and overall IDP players in the league. The problem is, in his first three
seasons in the league he has made "Fragile" Freddie Taylor look like
Jim "Iron Man" Marshall in comparison. During that span, he has never
missed LESS than 5 games (in '01 and '03) and was sidelined for half the season
in '02. His seriously checkered medical record includes a troubling history
of recurring concussions. He did finish the season with a bang... chalking up
13 tackles (11 solos) in the NFC Championship game against the Eagles. He played
like a man possessed in the Super Bowl and was seemingly everywhere on the field,
as if there were 2-3 clones on the field with him. While "officially"
credited with 18 tackles (also 11 solos), once the Panther coaching staff had
a chance to break down film of the game post-loss, he registered closer to 25
combined tackles. That is a half to a third of a SEASON for most mere mortal
LBs. If he can somehow manage to not skip a beat, and begin the year where he
left off last season, stringing together a few more games like the MONSTER Super
Bowl effort with greater consistency, he could be one of the SODs. The pedigree
is there... Morgan represents a leading edge of the Miami University MLB tradition,
a lineage which can be traced back to the rock solid Michael Barrow (WAS) and
first ballot Hall of Famer Ray Lewis (BAL), extending to the latest discovery
and first LB selected in the '03 draft, Jonathan Vilma (NYJ), who looks the
part of MLB prodigy. If the Panther's MLB can stay in one piece (he alluded
in the offseason to getting smarter and being more selective in when to go for
the killshot), getting him after 20-30 LBs are off the board could be comparable
value to those who took a chance on talented skill position players bearing
the stigma of the injury-prone tag like Robert Smith and Fred Taylor... the
year they had their breakthrough seasons. He was on pace for about 100 combined
tackles in '03, but if he can stay on the field and get in a groove, he has
the goods to easily surpass 100 SOLOS.
Bust: Chris Gamble (6'1" 181) ... one of a handful of the top pure
athletes in the entire draft, probably in the last decade. He is a winner who
has succeeded wherever he has competed... helping lead his high school basketball
team to a Florida state championship his junior year, reaching the same pinnacle
in football his senior season, a feat he was to repeat in college just two years
later. In the '02 season when Ohio State defeated Miami in the national championship
game, he brought back memories of Champ Bailey and Charles Woodson (still the
only primarily defensive player to win the Heisman trophy in NCAA history) as
two way superstars whose elite CBs skills weren't compromised by pulling double
duty as explosive WR weapons. Gamble demonstrated the stamina and endurance
of an iron man triathlete on adrenaline boosters. He is the culmination of a
line of fine pro CBs to emerge from the Buckeye program... including Shawn Springs,
Antoine Winfield (could be the best pound-for-pound open field tackler in the
NFL), Nate Clements and Ahmed Plummer. Despite being a world class athlete,
his CB technique is as raw as one would expect given that his first experience
with the position was goofing around with teammates prior to his sophomore season,
when not engaged in WR drills. He is not guaranteed a starting spot opposite
last seasons find Ricky Manning, but is talented enough to cast Artrell Hawkins
aside and push him to the bench. One place his inexperience manifests is in
open field tackling... next to his ragged, awkward arm tackles, he would make
Garo Yepremian look like a textbook form tackler (the Texans top 10 pick Dunta
Robinson is a man among boys from the '03 CB class in this department). INTs
could also be sparse if he gets turned around more often than the guest of honor
at a piñata party. Though his overall talent and athleticism could parlay
him into a winner for dynasty leagues (some scouts think with experience and
reps he will emerge as the best CB in the class), for redraft purposes... friends
don't let friends gamble on GAMBLE.
NEW ORLEANS SAINTS
By Bob Magaw
Sleeper: Courtney Watson (6'1" 246)... Watson is near the top of
the food chain of those rookies in the '03 class in contention for a starting
MLB job, including Jonathan Vilma (NYJ), Ted Lehman (DET) and Niko Koutouvides
(SEA). He represents possibly the best confluence of talent joined to opportunity.
The Saints were hoping that Vilma or D.J. Williams would drop to their first
round pick (1.18 '04), but things worked out for the best when they got Top
10 value with Big 10 Defensive Player of the Year Will Smith of Ohio State,
putting one of the fastest and best young D-Lines in the NFL over the top, and
still managed to land a likely starter in the middle for the next half decade,
when Watson fortuitously fell to them late in the second round. He was a three
year starter at MLB for Notre Dame, who was originally recruited as a RB, but
partly due to a lack of depth in the middle and the fact that his rock solid
frame and impressive physique lent itself to the switch, he was quickly ported
over to the important side of the ball. A tremendous athlete who began his prep
career as a WR, was two time all-city in basketball, once long jumped 23' and
was two time school champion at Notre Dame of one of the largest student run
5 on 5 basketball tournaments of its kind in the country. Perhaps his RB/WR
background and basketball cross-training conferred on him a playmakers ball
skills and open field running instincts... he finished his career with 7 INTs
and 2 TDs. Watson almost turned pro after a junior year with the Fighting Irish
that saw him garner first team All-American recognition. Improved in tackles
every season he was the starting MLB. Similar to MLB/WLB Daryl Smith of Georgia
Tech in that they are slightly undersized, All-American caliber MLBs with the
athleticism, range, versatility and power to play all three LB positions (the
Cowboy's drafted LSU's Bradie James in '03 for this handy trait), bring great
character, leadership and off-the-field intangibles to the table, and didn't
get the and recognition they deserved due to being in the same class with the
more acclaimed Vilma and Williams (though they were frequently mentioned by
scouts as Top 3 MLB/ILB prospects from their draft class). He capped off a stellar
career with one of the best workouts among his peers... one of a handful of
LBs (along with DJ, Vilma, Lehman, and the Vikings Dontarrius Thomas) to clock
a RB/safety-like 4.5 40, and some of his 5 on 5 opponents must have had his
tread marks on top of their heads with his gravity-defying 38" vertical.
With the freakishly talented MLB/CB mutant Cie Grant unable to get on the field
with chronic knee issues, expect Watson to emerge from the proverbial cast of
thousands vying for the coveted Saints MLB gig (whoever wins out gets to enjoy
the panoramic view behind an ascendant D-Line that might be the fastest in the
league). Top 20 status and 90+ solos are within his capability. And just as
importantly, within his reach with the rare opportunity to start at MLB as a
rookie. He looks like '04's Nick Barnett... only he is flying more under the
radar, as he was drafted a full round later. Barnett was the first LB selected
in '03... Watson didn't make it into the Top 5, and if he is as good as advertised,
will offer compelling value.
Bust: Darren Howard (6'3" 275)... the second pick in round two
of the 2000 draft, and bookend DE to up and coming Charles Grant. Last seasons
stats were skewed from missing the first half of the season (broken wrist).
After an auspicious debut in which he racked up 11 sacks his rookie year, he
slipped to 6 and 8 from '01-'02. Not as dangerous rushing the passer or in run
support as Grant, he was pacing to better his personal season solo total best
by almost 50% last season. With the selection of multi-skilled Will Smith, he
is now probably the third most talented DE on the roster. Howard won't get bumped
from the starting lineup in '04, but he is in a contract year and could easily
be supplanted by '05 for dynasty league purposes. Howard's opportunities could
be curtailed this season if Smith emerges as the best sack artist on the team...
his pedigree and ability suggest he could. He was somewhat overshadowed his
junior year when Ohio State defeated Miami for the national championship with
other high profile, front-line defensive talents like Mike Doss and Chris Gamble,
and his stats were held in check a little by a conservative scheme the past
few seasons... they were not representative of or commensurate with the havoc
he could have wreaked if he had been fully unleashed. If turned loose by HC
Haslett and DC Venturi, Smith has UFC-quality intensity and controlled fury,
and among the best measurables and athleticism at his position in the draft,
along with Kenechi Udeze (MIN). Has instincts that can't be taught, and is like
a much smaller LB in his instant run/pass recognition, ability to stay on his
feet and sift through traffic, sideline-to-sideline range and wrap up skills
once he gets there. The Saints are reportedly experimenting with a jailbreak
blitz personnel grouping called DELTA in which Grant and Howard shift inside
to DT, and Smith and WLB Derrick Rodgers flank them on the edge. If so, NFC
South O-Line opponents could be the victim of more stunts than a bootleg Bum
Fights shoot
TAMPA BAY BUCCANEERS
By Bob Magaw
Sleeper: DE Dewayne White (6'2" 273) was described by HC John Gruden
as the most improved player on the team in the offseason. One of the top defensive
players in the nation his sophomore year at Louisville, he was looking like
one of the best pure pass rush prospects in the past half decade (27 sacks in
his first two seasons combined... he had 7 sacks in the first four games his
junior year before a severe ankle sprain and intense O-Line attention directed
his way limited him during the balance of the season) . He came out as an underclassman,
the last pick in the second round of the '03 draft (2.32), though he was Tampa
Bay's first pick in the draft, dealing their first rounder that year to the
Raiders as part of the rare coach-for-picks trade of John Gruden. He was brought
along slowly by DC Kiffin and crew last year, and with only 3 solo tackles and
being shut out in the sack department, he is well below the typical IDP league's
radar screen. Many Buc insiders expect him to seize the job from incumbent Greg
Spires, if not immediately, than soon. Scouts have characterized his talent
as DD sack and All-Pro caliber.
BONUS Sleeper: SS Jermaine Phillips (6'1" 214) is a twenty five
year old former Georgia fifth rounder who came into the league with little fanfare
but may be peaking at the right time. Tampa Bay thought enough of his complete,
all-around game that they cut ties with local institution John Lynch, whose
play seemed to slip discernibly last season. He can run, hit and cover, like
his deep patrol counterpart and similarly gifted athletically, FS Dwight Smith.
He has been flashing so many multitalented skills in the offseason that he is
forcing the Buc defensive coaching staff to get creative in finding more and
more ways to exploit his talent and deploy his playmaking ability within the
overall defensive scheme. With ex-Bronco Ian Gold playing SLB, a position he
is unaccustomed to, and WLB Derrick Brooks appearing to bear the first marks
of Father Time taking his toll, he could be among the team's leading tacklers
this season.
Bust: Greg Spires (see above)... his job is extremely vulnerable to
being taken by the more talented DeWayne White. Gruden and company want to reap
some dividends on their investment in their top pick in the '03 draft.
Bonus Bust: Ian Gold could be miscast as a SLB. Listed at 6'0"
and just over 220, he looks more like a skinny possession WR or a run supporting
SS than a LB. Early returns are good, yet there are legitimate questions that
have yet to be answered about how well he will bounce back from a torn ACL suffered
last season, as well as how quickly and smoothly he will make the transition
to his new, more brutal and physically punishing role lined up over the TE and
opposing the strong side of the offensive formation. As a Bronco WLB, he was
kept clean of blocks for the most part and freed up to chase from the backside
and leverage his greatest attribute... his exceptional range and sideline-to-sideline
speed. Gold not only has WR/S-type size, but also speed. In fact he is faster
than many safeties and skill position players with bonafide pre-ACL injury 4.4
speed. He is sure to be run right at and smashmouth-tested early and often as
one of the smaller SLBs in the NFL. If he tries to run around blocks, he may
take himself out of too many plays. If he has to get on the job training and
learn on the fly the bruising art and skill of stacking and shedding, getting
off blocks and sifting through traffic, with his undersized frame, his knee
could get seriously buggered up. They are said to be grooming him to supplant
Brooks as soon as next season, but if he gets killed playing out of position
this year, that could prove to be a moot point. Fans who know him from his outstanding
100 tackle sophomore season in '02, his first as Denver's starting WLB, could
be disappointed with the anticipated drop in tackle production and playmaking
opportunities from the more Neanderthal-like SLB slot.
ARIZONA CARDINALS
By David Baker
Sleeper: Defensive Tackle is not a position in FF that many care much
about. Typically, they do not produce big numbers in sacks or tackles. And like
a cornerback, it seems that the more talented you are in NFL terms, the less
valuable you are in FF terms. At DT, the best ones often get double-teamed.
Indeed, defenses often desire their DT's to eat up space to allow the LB's to
make plays. There are always exceptions to the rule, though. Warren Sapp has
played mostly DT his entire career and has produced 9 or more sacks in 4 seasons.
Another exception could very well be Darnell Dockett (6'4" 301) of Arizona,
who was drafted in the 2004 draft in the third round. Dockett came out of Florida
State where he broke a career school record for tackles made behind the line
of scrimmage. Regarded by many as the best DE coming out of high school, Dockett
went on to have a stellar career at FSU. Dockett is known for his tremendous
explosion off the snap and has rare speed for his position. HC Dennis Green
already has been trying to play Dockett some at DE and had named Dockett the
starter at DT almost from the moment he came into camp. He can collapse the
pocket as quick as anyone can. With DT Kenny King injured and will now likely
miss the season, Dockett becomes that much more likely to start and get increased
playing time. With John Randle, Dennis Green had a player that could set the
tone with penetration ability and intensity. It looks like more of the same
with Dockett. I still occasionally watch the Senior Bowl from last year, and
Dockett's speed and ability to get into the backfield was something I have not
seen in a long time.
Bust: Dexter Jackson (6'0" 210) had a coming out year of sorts
for the Cards last season. The 4th round choice in 1999 for Tampa Bay, Jackson
came to the Cards last year and ended up with career highs in tackles (75) and
INTs (6). His biggest claim to fame, though, had been winning the Super Bowl
MVP while with the Tampa Bay Bucs in their championship year of 2002. Jackson
won the award after intercepting two Rich Gannon passes in the first half. So
after his nice year with the Cards last season, there were high expectations
for him in 2004. Unfortunately, he's missed much of training camp this year
with a disk problem in his back. Quentin Harris was named the starter over Jackson
in June. With the signing of hard-hitting free agent Ifyeani Ohalete, the future
does not look so bright for Jackson this year.
SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS
By David Baker
Sleeper: Derek Smith (6'2" 245) has been a very productive and
reliable NFL LB as soon as he was drafted by the Redskins in the 3rd round in
1997. He's started all but three games in his NFL career. Last year, Smith had
a career high 87 tackles with 12 assists and a career high 3.5 sacks. Smith
has led the 49ers in tackles the last three seasons. He is a smart, disciplined
player who excels against the run. Smith was also good friends with former ASU
teammate Pat Tillman, the Arizona DB who was killed in action in Afghanistan.
Smith keeps a memorial card from Tillman's services with him at all times. He
often thinks of Tillman as he runs out to the practice field. He's dedicating
the season to him. Now heading into the 2004 season, Smith's numbers could grow
even higher. With fellow LB Julian Peterson's contract still an issue, the team
will be even more reliant on Smith. Whether at ILB or OLB, I like Smith to have
a big year.
Bust: Andre Carter (6'4" 265) is the much lauded 7th pick overall
for the 49ers in the 2001 draft. In 2002, Carter had a very nice season, finishing
with 12.5 sacks and 45 tackles. For the most part, though, the rest of his career
has centered on unfulfilled expectations. Carter remains the teams' best pass
rusher, but opposing tackles have been known to overpower him. He still has
a dangerously quick first step, though, and he has a solid blend of speed, power
and hand control. The 49ers say they are establishing new defensive schemes
to offer Carter more chance to use his speed, but the 3-4 fronts with Carter
playing some at LB sounds troubling. As much as the 49ers say they are hoping
to give Carter better chances to get to the QB, it seems more to me like they
are simply experimenting in various ways to make Carter earn his keep. I believe
this experiment will be a failure.
SEATTLE SEAHAWKS
By Bob Magaw
Sleeper: Ken Hamlin (6'2" 209)... the tenth pick in the second
round of the 2003 draft conjured up memories of Kenny Easley, a Seahawk blast
from the past who possessed a multitasking skill set, and was both superb in
coverage as well as a monster in run support. Hamlin had some injury issues
in the second half, but if first half production was doubled, the 86 solo tackles
generated would have led the team (LBs included), been good for third among
all NFL safeties (the Patriots Rodney Harrison had 94 and the Chiefs Greg Wesley
racked up 90), fourth among all DBs (the Vikings CB Antoine Winfield had 96
with the Bills) and just missed a Top 25 finish among LINEBACKERS (and within
a handful of the top rookie, Green Bay's stud MLB Nick Barnett). With OLB/SS
conversion Michael Boulware slated to start sooner rather than later, with the
expected and given growing pains, he could be the atypical FS heavily involved
in and counted on for run support. Breaking down different forms of knowledge
about IDP prospects can be useful. Info related to measurables (height and weight,
40 time, vertical jump, strength reps, etc.) and pedigree (how did they do in
high school and college, what awards did they win, where were they drafted)
can easily be referenced on the internet. Knowledge conferred by watching film
of a prospect (in answer to questions such as: does a safety prospect have good
run/pass read and recognition skills, instincts, take good angles to the ball,
exhibit good range, ball skills, open field tackling technique and wrap up form?)
falls into a different category. The first type concerning physical measurables
and pedigree is important, but it should be complemented with and supported
by the higher level kind, which frames and provides context for the former.
Another example of different levels, where some types of info are nested within
others of greater importance, is that of stats... and the ability to spot patterns
and trends within the stats... OR, info such as FBG and Ourlads depth charts
being different from that set of knowledge pertaining to defensive systems and
schemes, coaching tendencies, implications of personnel movement in the offseason,
etc. Placing the various streams of info in context and the different levels
and strands of knowledge into perspective can help crack the code of scoring
fluctuations from season to season, morph noise into signal, and make the IDP
world more of an open book and forecast/prognostication-friendly. Hamlin was
the #19 DB and #81 Overall IDP in FBG's expert rankings as of time of writing
this survey. If he can stay healthy and avoid some of the off-the-field issues
that could still cloud his future, your opponents may not know what hit them...
like his signature decleater of Donte' Stallworth that saw heavy rotation on
Sports Center last season. BOOYAH!
Bust: Grant Wistrom (6'4" 272)... his main claim to fame was having
one of the top blond 'fros in the NFL. His signing was considered a significant
event in the offseason free agency landscape, as much for the weakening of Seattle's
key divisional rival the Rams, as for the boost to the Seahawks... it could
represent a rift in the vortex that is the NFC West balance of power. He is
less than a superstar but more than a journeyman and "steady Eddie".
Wistrom has averaged nearly 50 solo stops since 2000, and come away with a haul
of 11, 9, 5 and 8 sacks within that span. If he plays with the same kind of
hustle, nonstop motor and relentlessness he demonstrated in St. Louis, those
kind of numbers are reproducible. Some key differences between the Rams and
Seahawks... Wistrom won't have the benefit of a DE bookend the caliber of Leonard
Little across from him to deflect attention and O-Line resources from. Seattle
has one of the most athletic, talented and versatile young secondaries in the
league... with the emphasis on young. With aforementioned rookie SS Boulware
expected to crack the starting lineup soon if not by opening day, and Hamlin
and future cover CB/shutdown artist Marcus Trufant coming off THEIR rookie seasons,
flashes of brilliance could be interspersed with uneven play. The Seahawks were
statistically awful and one of the worst teams in 2003 against the pass specifically.
It is unclear if Wistrom's new secondary will be able to blanket opposing WRs
as competently and buy him the kind of time he translated into sacks with the
Rams? Hamlin and Trufant are a year older, and hopefully wiser, and a resurgent
CB Ken Lucas and renegade Eagle Bobby Taylor could comprise key pieces to the
puzzle of Seattle's pass defense. Wistrom is a driven, high character individual
who will not lay down and get fat and sloppy now that he landed an unexpected
jackpot $14 million signing bonus... he will no doubt work harder than ever
to justify it. He is that kind of person and player. But for those who tend
to see the glass as half full, and are hoping for an uptick from Wistrom's FBG
consensus Top 20 DE ranking into the lofty top 10 stratosphere, could just as
easily be disappointed by a decline into the more pedestrian Top 30. One other
aspect in his favor (one man's bust is another's sleeper)... the Seahawks have
an extremely balanced, dangerous and powerhouse offense with no such questions
on that side of the ball. Bigger leads quickly attained, SHOULD = more opponent
passing playing catch-up, COULD = more sack opps if things break right for the
former Ram/Cornhusker.
ST. LOUIS RAMS
By Bob Magaw
Sleeper: Pisa Tinoisamoa (6'1" 235)... a San Diego prep legend,
the only high school football player in regional history to win All-CIF honors
on offense AND defense (impressive when taking into account probable future
Hall of Famers Marcus Allen and Junior Seau are among the native bred talent).
Running with the wrong crowd in high school led to a conviction for taking part
in a fight while on probation, landing him a detention stint, and causing Division
I interest and scholarship offers to stop cold, understandably. Hawaii head
coach (and former Falcons HC) June Jones took a chance on his prodigious athleticism,
and by all accounts Tino embraced the opportunity to simultaneously flash his
futuristic array of skills and demonstrate that he had turned his life around.
Despite playing at a safety-like 210-215 in college, he impressed combine scouts
by bulking up to 230 and still managing to clock by far the fastest 10 yard
dash split and cone drill times among LB prospects... in fact, they were comparable
to the top CB times in the '03 draft. More than one scout said he looked like
the best player on the field at the Senior Bowl and the week of practices leading
up to it. It would have been hard to have a more auspicious debut than his steady
and at times spectacular production during his inaugural season. The final tally
on his seasonal stat log showed 80 tackles (67 solos & 13 assists), 2 sacks,
3 INTs & 4 FFs (he is a devastating striker who brings the pain via well
schooled form, disciplined wrap up technique and blunt force trauma). Only a
handful of veteran LBs had as many INTs OR FFs. 5-0 was the only player in the
NFL last year to show up so high in BOTH stat leader board columns. He couples
rare speed, quickness, power, instincts and intensity and is the whole package.
Already the Ram's top LB, he has the kind of work ethic to get better... a LOT
better. When he is covered up and sees the play unfold, he has the game to be
dominant. One of the most promising young playmaking LBs and ascendant talents
in the NFL... a Samoan Derrick Brooks in his prime.
Bonus Sleeper: Robert Thomas (6'1" 237)... has been dinged a lot
in his first two seasons, and was written off after struggling in '02 with his
rookie season adjustment to SLB. After being returned to his more familiar and
comfortable MLB role (he was Pac-10 Defensive Player of the Year there at UCLA),
the former first rounder (1.31 '02) actually led the Rams in tackles during
the first month of last season. One of the faster and more athletic MLBs in
the NFL, if he can avoid the training room he is a good bet to be a steal, and
greatly outperform his ADP.
Bust: Damione Lewis (6'2" 301)... the number 12 has not been kind
to the Rams of late. The highly regarded Miami DT Lewis was billed as a Warren
Sapp protégé and was the 12th selection in the '01 draft (the
Ram's first of three first rounders in that draft, including SS Adam Archuleta
and fellow-DT Ryan "Big Grease" Pickett). Jimmy Kennedy fell to the
12th pick in the '03 draft... they just missed out on stud CB Marcus Trufant
when the Seahawks snatched him away from them at #11. So far the only shared
traits by Lewis and Kennedy are having a broken foot injury in their past (Lewis
has broken his foot a few times... Kennedy is done for the season) and being
colossal busts. Not the kind of common denominators you want your interior D-Linemen
to have. Lewis "good" year was in '02 when he managed to play in all
16 games and scuffle up a feeble 15 solo tackles and 4 sacks. His rookie year
he suited up for 9 games and logged 9 tackles (when the total in the tackle
column doesn't exceed the total in the games played column for your prospective
IDP stud, that tends to be a bad sign) and no sacks. Last season he missed a
quarter of the season, and was yet again unable to best his games played total
with his solo tackle total (12 & 12), adding 1 sack. Lewis has been extremely
unproductive, but he compensates for that by being injury prone (he's slow...
but he is weak, too). Even in deeper leagues that distinguish DL into DE and
DT, not a player to target on draft day, unless some exotic leagues pop up which
require each team starting 20 DTs.
Bonus Bust: Tommy Polley is in serious danger of being relegated to
the bench. There have been rumblings for a while that the coaching staff is
dissatisfied with his toughness and consistency in run support. First he gave
up his WLB position to Tino in the offseason, flipping to SLB. Now several other
candidates, including '04 fourth round pick Brandon Chillar, are taking reps
with the first team at SLB. Polley was probably going to be allowed to walk
in free agency next season anyway (he has regressed badly since his promising
rookie season). It looks like he could be on the outside looking in sooner than
expected.
DENVER BRONCOS
By Bob Magaw
Sleeper: D.J. Williams, OLB (6'0" 247)... probably an even better
athlete than the Ram's Pisa Tinoisamoa (Hawaii 5-0 the only football player
in San Diego County history to be awarded All-CIF honors on BOTH sides of the
ball, for his work at RB and LB). D.J. was the consensus top recruit in the
nation, capping a storied career at perennial prep powerhouse Concord De La
Salle with a 40+ TD senior year, being selected USA Today's Defensive Player
of the Year and signing a letter of intent with NFL feeder team the Miami Hurricanes.
After a freshman season spent dabbling at fullback, he was switched full time
to WLB, where he played ever since. His thunder was stolen somewhat by the less
heralded MLB Jonathan Vilma, who led Miami in tackles the past few seasons.
Still, many scouts considered Williams the superior prospect all the way through
college. In the end, Vilma didn't drop as some predicted due to concerns that
he didn't embody the physical prototype for a MLB/ILB at 230 (first LB off the
board at 1.12 to the Jets), & D.J. went about where he was expected to (second
LB selected at 1.17 to the Broncos; though Shanahan reportedly coveted the Buc's
good looking WR Michael Clayton with the slot he acquired from the Bengals).
This was a classic case where value intersected with need, as Denver allowed
incumbent WLB Ian Gold to walk when they had a difference of opinion with his
representation the Poston brothers over his post-knee injury value. In his first
season as the starter in '02, Gold had nearly 90 solo tackles and 7 sacks...
D.J. is about 25 lbs heavier, and probably his equal in the agility and speed
departments (they have both been timed in the 4.4 range, and Williams is said
to have a Kobe & Lebron-like 38" vertical). He should be immediately
thrust into a prominent role on the defense. Expect some growing pains, as he
doesn't possess Vilma's telepathic run/pass recognition and instincts. Lavar
Arrington could be a comp player in terms of overall athleticism, and in that
if Williams is turned loose in the scheme, he could be one of the top blitzing
LBs in the game.
Bust: John Lynch, SS (6'2" 220)... this former LYNCH-pin was the
heart and soul of the great Tampa Bay defenses, along with Warren Sapp and Derrick
Brooks, that were the scourge of the old NFC Central division, and now the NFC
South. He is a warrior in the domain of real football, and his toughness and
punishing, reckless tackling style with no regard for his body helped set the
tempo for the Buc's fearsome brand of defense for the better part of a decade.
In his prime, he compensated for a lack of raw speed with his football smarts
& veteran wiliness. You rarely saw Lynch take a false step, or moving in
any direction other than towards the ball carrier... until last season. He turns
33 on 9.25 of this year, and Tampa Bay released him in part because they wanted
to clear the decks for the talented and promising Jermaine Phillips, but also
because they thought his play slipped last year, and he was a player in decline
with eroding skills. Despite his deserved reputation as a knock out artist,
in terms of pure production his tackle numbers have been decidedly mixed...
only 42 solos in '02 and 52 solos in an injury curtailed season last year. The
most disturbing sign is that Lynch didn't stick his head in as much last season
as in the past, probably related to the fact that a recurring neck stinger condition
surfaced in '03 that caused many Buc insiders to surmise that he would call
it a career. Buyer beware... his upside may not be that great if his subpar
tackle numbers of the past few seasons are any indication, and prove to be a
harbinger of disappointment. His downside? One neck-traumatizing tackle too
many shelves him for the season, relegating him to full time Campbell's Chunky
Soup hawking, and the analyst booth gig his charismatic, telegenic presence
and soaring, off the charts football IQ would seem to command and make him destined
for.
KANSAS CITY CHIEFS
By Bob Magaw
Sleeper: Eric Hicks, DE (6'6" 280)... the definition of an up and
down career. Made his way to the Chiefs the hard way, as an undrafted free agent
from Maryland. He had his best season in 2000, when he was #4 in sacks among
all NFL DEs with 14, and his next best year was '02 with a top 20 finish for
a DE with 9 sacks. Cutting him some slack for a nondescript rookie season, his
good years have been interspersed with lackluster efforts in '99, '01 and '03,
in which he got 4, 4, and 5 sacks, respectively. Maybe he is like an Eric Moulds
of DEs... he is notorious for following up stellar even-numbered years with
mediocre odd-numbered ones. If so, the arrow is pointed up by the calendar.
A more substantive reason to like Hicks in 2004 is that his best season occurred
under the watch of former HC/DC (and current DC) Gunther Cunningham, who is
back in a rare repeat performance after an interim stint as the Titan's LB coach.
He was clearly the Chief's most important offseason defensive acquisition, as
they will stick with a pat hand for the most part, personnel-wise, and are counting
on internal improvement to get better. Former DC Greg Robinson's defensive conception
was riddled with stunts and line games, and in the process of trying to confuse
opponents ended up stupefying themselves (we have found the enemy, and it is
us). Gun's system allows the D-Line to be football players, attack upfield,
find the ball and blow the play up, and with his fiery demeanor and intensity
lighting a fire under the defense's collective posteriors, a return to DD sacks
for Hicks is a distinct possibility.
Bust: Mike Maslowski, MLB (6'1" 243)... Maslowski missed a lot
of games last season with a balky knee... he may not be a good bet to play 16
games. The point at which the wheels came off in Kansas City's season coincided
closely with the juncture when Maslowski suffered his knee injury and was unable
to get on the field. Rookie MLB Kawika Mitchell is a physical specimen with
ridiculous measurables, but was as raw as an undercooked prime rib. The latest
word from camp is that Maslowski's knee injury has been refractory to surgical
intervention and rehab, and continues to be painful and swollen. His quickness,
lateral movement and change of direction skills, never a strong suit (he outworked
and out-studied his peers), have been reduced to a shell of his former capability.
Maslowski is a big favorite of the fiercely loyal Dick Vermeil, but even if
he cries a river, the tears won't obscure his vision or prevent him from stripping
away any sentiment about hanging on to a player whose injuries make him a liability
on the field. Vermeil has already alluded recently to the need to move in another
direction if the knee doesn't improve rapidly, seemingly an unlikely proposition
given that the pain has lingered through the entire offseason. As much as they
will miss his veteran savvy, knowing which spot to get to won't make a difference
if his battered joint precludes him from getting there. It is more likely that
leading candidates Kawika Mitchell and dark horse Monty Beisel, who have the
physical tools to fill the MLB responsibilities, can be coached up. If Maslowski
can't go, the sooner they get reps the better, to ease the transition to being
the starter at a critically important position. There is too much at stake this
season for Vermeil and the Chiefs to allow the defense to let the offense down
again (the last time we saw them, Peyton Manning dissected them for 400+ yards,
5 TDs in an AFC playoff game, and the Colts never punted).
OAKLAND RAIDERS
By David Baker
Sleeper: Tyler Brayton (6'6" 280) was the Raiders first round draft
choice in 2003, the 32nd pick overall. He was Colorado's unquestioned leader
in college. Brayton seems to be blessed with an array of speed, strength, stamina
and intelligence. He's one of those guys with a motor that won't quit. It's
an old adage, but Brayton definitely leaves everything on the field. His rookie
season was fine, but not up to speed with what the Raiders or Brayton expected.
Still, he proved to be an anchor on his side of the line, while the rest of
the line seemed to be revamped from game to game. He ended up with 48 tackles,
13 assists and 2.5 sacks. In his second season, Brayton will get the chance
to play alongside of, and learn from, the likes of Warren Sapp and Ted Washington.
It's hard to come up with a better person to learn how to get to a QB and understand
blocking schemes that Warren Sapp. So while Brayton is still working on his
moves, the Raiders will employ both a 3-4 and 4-3 defense. In the 4-3, look
for Brayton to play end. In the 3-4, Brayton will either play end or move to
LB to take advantage of his motor. The biggest issues Brayton had last year
dealt with inexperience and the lack of support along the line. He now is a
year more experienced and with Sapp and Washington, his support has increased
tenfold. Also, Brayton played on the left side in college and switched sides
when he came to Oakland. He now has a year in the same position. I see a big
year for Brayton.
Bust: When Napoleon Harris (6'3" 255) was drafted in the first
round, 23rd overall, in the 2002 NFL draft by the Raiders, many believed he
was the best LB coming out that year. In his rookie year, Harris had his shares
of ups and downs as he learned the pro game. Last season, in his second year,
Harris started to come around a little more and became a leader on the field
and a solid LB. But he was also a bit inconsistent against the run. And his
numbers were mediocre (74 tackles, 33 assists and 2 sacks), especially when
compared to the LB's in the game Harris was being compared to in talent. But
Harris remains a big talent nonetheless who many are expecting a big year this
year. However, a knee injury during a training camp drill in preseason likely
means Harris misses some time. Harris tore cartilage in his right knee and underwent
arthroscopic surgery on August 10th. Although Harris says he plans to be back
by opening day, don't count on it. He'll likely miss a game or two and it's
questionable how effective he'll immediately be upon his return. So while some
might have thought Harris would be a solid #2 LB in FF, I had him at a #3 prior
to the injury and am wary now of drafting him as a starter.
SAN DIEGO CHARGERS
By Bob Magaw
Sleeper: Terrence Kiel, SS (5'11" 207)... his rookie year didn't
get off to a good start last offseason with an attempted carjacking in which
he was shot multiple times. Fully recovered now, and with a year in the system,
he could be the one jacking up WRs who venture across the middle this season.
An extremely productive tackler at Texas A & M, the second rounder flashed
enough ability last season to suggest he could have the goods to be a force
in run support. This up 'n coming SS is somewhat overshadowed in a secondary
that sports consecutive first rounders selected in the '02 and '03 drafts, the
CB tandem of Quentin Jammer and fellow-Aggie Sammy (Candy Man) Davis. He went
in the same round of the draft as other potentially elite NFL safeties Ken Hamlin
(SEA), Mike Doss (IND) and Bryan Scott (ATL), and he has a chance to be similarly
productive... if so, he will far surpass his ADP value. It doesn't hurt that
San Diego could have one of the most anemic offenses in the league after LT
II, and opponents could be playing with a substantial lead early and often in
2004, therefor grinding the clock with a disproportionate amount of runs in
fourth quarter/s. Coupled with one of the worst front sevens in the league (with
the exception of the ageless and venerable Donnie Edwards), this could be a
recipe for a tackle engine.
Bust: Igor Olshansky, DE (6'6" 309)... another second rounder (35th
overall pick - '04) might be one of the strongest players in the league. The
Ukrainian Polar Bear (the first known NFL player, at any position, to hale from
the former Soviet republic) got in an epic fire against ice battle with Hawaii's
Isaac Sopoaga when they took turns trying to break the combine strength record,
both managing 40 throws of the 225 bar... Olshansky must have gotten primed
for strength test showdowns with Herculean Samoans lifting alongside the frightening
Junior "Tidal Wave" Siavii (KC) while at Oregon. Though an interior
lineman whose forte was stopping the run in college, the second team All Pac-10
DT has surprising speed, agility and athleticism for a big man and racked up
6.5 sacks his junior year. HC Schottenheimer and DC Phillips are expected to
move him outside as a 3-4 DE, but it would be asking a lot for a player to not
only make the transition from college to pro D-Lineman (as an underclassman,
no less), but also to undergo a position switch his rookie year. Marcellus Wiley
could have deflected attention away from him as the opposing DE, but he was
lost to the Cowboys in free agency. Longer-term and dynasty-wise, his intriguing
measurables could project him to be a better Aaron Smith, a run stuffing 3-4
end capable of getting after the QB on a good day. Not in the same class as
'04 first rounders Kenechi Udeze (MIN) and Will Smith (NO) as a pass rushing
DE prospect.
HOUSTON TEXANS
By By Aaron Rudnicki
Sleeper: CB Dunta Robinson
Robinson was described by Mel Kiper as the best run support CB to enter the
draft in 5 years so he should be able to rack up plenty of tackles on the NFL's
#32 ranked run defense from last season. He's a former safety who has only been
playing CB for 2 years, but he has been given a starting CB job in Houston,
allowing the Texans to move Marcus Coleman over to FS. Robinson has adequate
size for a CB at 5'10", 186 lbs, but he has phenomenal range (4.34 40)
and athletic ability (36" vertical) that should allow him to stay with
any WR once he improves his technique. With Aaron Glenn playing opposite him,
teams should look to test the rookie early and often this year, which is normally
a good thing for fantasy purposes. He still has to work to do on his ball skills
so he probably won't pick off too many of those passes, but when it comes to
tackles and PDs, he could be a very solid fantasy DB this year. Terence Newman,
Marcus Trufant, and Charles Tillman racked up 66, 69, and 74 solo tackles last
year, respectively. If the Texans continue to struggle on offense and defense,
it would not be all that surprising if Robinson were to wind up with 75 solo
tackles along with an INT or 2 and finish among the top-20 fantasy DBs.
Bust: LB Jason Babin
Babin played DE in college but will be converted to OLB in the Texans 3-4 scheme.
He was a bit of a workout warrior whose value rose very quickly in the weeks
leading up to the draft. He ran a very good 40 time at the combine (4.64) so
he definitely has the speed to play the position, but he won't be used to playing
out in space and will almost certainly need more time to adjust before he gets
completely comfortable. He was a dominant pass rusher in college at Western
Michigan and has a nonstop motor, but some have questioned the level of competition
he faced and the jump from the MAC to the NFL is pretty big. He's expected to
start on the strong side and will be used primarily as a rush end, but he will
still need to drop into coverage on occasion. Regardless of how quickly he makes
the adjustment to his new position, he is not likely to make much of a fantasy
impact as Jamie Sharper and Jay Foreman will accumulate most of the tackles
from the LB position. The Texans are hoping that Babin will give them a more
consistent pass rush and are not necessarily relying on him for too much else.
Jeff Posey's numbers from 2002 (45 solos, 8.0 sacks) probably represent the
best possible outcome to expect from Babin this year, but realistically his
numbers will likely end up considerably lower.
INDIANAPOLIS COLTS
By Bob Magaw
Sleeper: David Thornton (6'2" 230)... Thornton burst on to the
scene out of relative obscurity for the Colts in '03, going from an unheralded
second day pick (4.09 '02) who was a North Carolina walk on with only one good
collegiate season on his resume, before being a little known backup to stud
WLB Mike Peterson with Indianapolis (before he was released and allowed to depart
to the Jaguars in free agency)... to a 5th place finish in solo tackles among
NFL LBs (117)... and overall among all IDPs. Donnie Edwards (SD), who tied for
the NFL lead with MLB Keith Brooking (ATL), was the only WLB to finish with
more solos than Thornton... Ray Lewis (BAL) and Jamie Sharper (HOU) were barely
eclipsed by Edwards and Brooking with 125 and 124 solos, but they play MLB and
ILB for their respective teams. For the second offseason. in a row the Colts
suffered attrition from the LB ranks, letting SLB Marcus Washington jump ship
to the Redskins. Surprisingly, rather than plug in some journeyman at SLB, HC
Dungy and DC Ron Meeks chose to slide Thornton over and replace him at WLB...
Cato June and Gilbert Gardner get first shot at the position. This is noteworthy
because SLBs typically don't get as many tackle opportunities as the WLB (who
in most schemes, are covered up and protected from blockers better than their
strong side counterparts... the red headed, freckled stepchildren of LBs) and
for the most part there seems to be a consensus opinion that Thornton's chances
to be a playmaker will dry up, and his productivity will plummet. A key to IDP
success is knowing the "rules" well enough to know when you can bend
them, if not break them. Having a handle on systems and schemes (see the definitive
articles by John Norton and Bob Henry) arms you with the principles you need
to form judgments and come to conclusions about whether a player falls into
the class of players that proves a given rule, or the set of players that is
the exception to the rule. A lot of rankings flip flopped Thornton and June
(moving the former down and the latter up) with the announcement of the new
roles and starting assignments. Based on early returns, Thornton has looked
like a beast and capable of blowing up ball carriers as effortlessly from the
strong side as his ex-position... that rare SLB that can still live large and
in charge (like Lavar Arrington and Pisa Tinoisamoa last season, and Anthony
Simmons, Julian Peterson and Scott Fujita in '04). Conversely, the jury is still
up in the air on Cato June, who could be replaced by Gilbert Gardner (comes
from a program that well prepares prospects for the mental rigors of a prostyle
defense; Purdue saw four LBs taken in the '03 draft) before or during the season,
at any time. Thornton has a good head on his shoulders (former student body
president and national honor student as a prep) and has taken a team first approach
about the move. Rather than making excuses and setting himself up for failure,
he is attending exclusively to those matters that can propel him to becoming
the best SLB for the Colts possible. Situated next to the plodding and ponderous
Rob Morris at MLB, and absent any outstanding run stuffing DEs in front of him,
don't be surprised if Thornton once again cruises to the team lead in solo tackles.
Bust: Idrees Bashir (6'2" 198)... a high second rounder (2.06 '01)
from Memphis who has flashed enough potential in the past to tease with his
athleticism but ultimately disappointed in the past two seasons, after an initially
promising rookie effort. There has been a pronounced and alarming downward trend
in his stats the first three seasons... 15 games and 61 solos in his rookie
year, 14 games and 37 solos in a sophomore jinx year, all the way down to 9
games and 29 solos in '03. If he keeps it up, it will be hard to shirk the label
of being injury prone. There is a good chance that his days are numbered as
the Colts FS of the future... he may not even be the FS of the present much
longer, due to the selection of Iowa's SS Bob Sanders in the second round (44th
overall pick) of the most recent draft. Some pundits were scratching their heads
over the pick at the time. The "Hitman", as he is cheerfully referred
to by opposing WRs, seemed like a Mike Doss-clone... a short (but not small),
devastating, lights out hitter... but Doss was already their SS. Dungy shed
some light on the thought process behind the selection during a draft day interview,
in which he laid out his plan for Sanders to be a FS, and to be a key piece
to the puzzle of their run defense. He is just shy of 5'9", but outweighs
stud top 20 SS Mike Minter (CAR) by over 10 lbs. The "Hitman" is a
little stick of dynamite who led the Hawkeyes in FFs last season, and if he
weren't involved in a protracted training camp holdout while he awaits a contract
agreement, he has the measurables (4.3 40 and 41"+ vertical), talent, explosiveness,
instincts, field awareness and innate run support skills to have already seized
the job from Bashir. In fact, Sander's charisma, leadership and indomitable
will X-factor are capable of being a catalyst to changing the tempo of games,
and will prove instrumental to elevating the intensity and toughness level of
the entire Colts defense.
JACKSONVILLE JAGUARS
By Bob Magaw
Sleeper: Daryl Smith (6'2" 234)... there are quite a few things
to like about Smith. He has been one of the top LBs in the nation for Georgia
Tech the past four years, and transitioned to college quickly and easily, with
a freshman All-American season. His segue way to the NFL has looked just as
effortless, and his pro-caliber LB chops have been on display during a spectacular
training camp and preseason. It is rare for a rookie to storm on to the scene
in such an advanced and developed state. Smith may be that unusual prospect
with the natural talent and an array of skills already fully formed and complete.
Mel Kiper included him in his Top 25 list leading up to the draft, just behind
the gifted MLB prodigy Jonathan Vilma (NYJ). In most IDP drafts he was selected
after not only Vilma and Miami teammate D.J. Williams (the first two LBs off
the board in the actual draft), who were more highly touted by most scouts,
but also Ted Lehman (DET), Karlos Dansby (ARI) and Dontarrius Thomas (MIN),
who in the wake of the draft appeared to have better opportunities and a clearer
path to starting (they all subsequently earned the nod in preseason.). It wasn't
clear where Smith would play... Mike Peterson and Akin Ayodele seemed firmly
ensconced at the MLB and WLB positions, respectively (and a crowded scene at
SLB, with veterans Favors and Hendricks competing). A season-ending knee injury
to good looking rookie LB/DE-tweener Jorge Cordova and the release of DE Tony
Brackens curbed the Jaguars enthusiasm for their DE stable, prompting the reinsertion
of former Purdue DE Ayodele back to his old collegiate position. This got Smith
a foot in the door at WLB more quickly than anticipated... expect him to break
it down. Del Rio must have been impressed by Smith's capabilities and potential
in the scheme, which was good for a #2 finish against the run in '03. The Jaguars
HC was of course a fine LB himself, and should be a good judge of talent, having
played with All-Pro Duane Bickett when they were at USC, as well as coaching
Ray Lewis for the Ravens. Ayodele got 96 solos and 20 assists from the WLB spot
in '03 (he didn't play WLB the whole year, but was moved there in-season), and
he was not even as highly touted a prospect (3.24 '02) as Smith (2.07 '04).
Sometimes in the IDP world it makes sense to go with the pedigree... the cream
will rise to the top.
Bust: Ayodele (see above)... he could turn out to be a quality DE, but
there is an element of uncertainty associated with the metamorphosis of the
former Boilermaker DE from SLB - WLB - back to DE. The change of status from
borderline Top 20 LB to question mark at DE has to be disappointing for dynasty
owners. If he is going to have his hand on the ground full-time, it could take
a season or two polishing his inside moves, expanding his repertoire of counter
moves, and becoming adept at stringing moves together. His positional change
really muddles attempts to project his tackle productivity based on last seasons
numbers. It is such a fundamental alteration to his prospects that his projections
have to be completely reconsidered... from scratch. One ray of hope is that
he will enjoy playing alongside Marcus Stroud and John Henderson, arguably the
most athletic, stoutest and formidable young DT tandem in the league. While
on the subject of Jacksonville DEs, beware of Hugh Douglas (6'2" 281),
too. He may have been a product of the Eagle's complex, intricate and relentless
blitz schemes. Douglas just turned 33, is coming off a shockingly bad 4 sack
season and the volume on the scout chatter has been raised a few decibels, increasingly
suggesting that he looks done.
TENNESSEE TITANS
By Bob Magaw
Sleeper: Tank Williams (6'3" 223)... Clevan "Tank" Williams
is a tremendous athlete who was a QB/DB, basketball player and competed in track
as a highly regarded Lone Star state prep. He received some All-American consideration
his senior year at Stanford, when he had 68 tackles, 5 INTs and 2 sacks. Tank
was the first safety taken (2.13 '02) after first rounders Roy Williams (DAL)
and Ed Reed (BAL), and before highly regarded Michael Lewis (PHI). The Titans
were intrigued by his legit 4.4 40, thunder dunk-friendly 38"+ vertical
and ability to get "medieval" on ball carriers in run support... he
is as big as a LB and as fast as a CB. Williams has played all 32 games in his
first two seasons. Hunting sleepers and running them to ground sometimes entails
identifying material changes to an IDP prospect from one season to the next.
If you think that being able to raise his right arm over his head this year
(his shoulder was so damaged during most of last season that his arm was basically
useless) could positively impact on his tackle stats, than you have identified
such a material change. Snippets of info like that, easily uncovered through
the interconnected information push that is the FBG news blogger, daily updates
and message boards, when used in concert, can be the difference between winning
and losing. Looking back on his injury-blighted season after surgery on the
labrum and rotator cuff, he observed... ''It just hinders you, being like that...
You just can't play as physical and aggressively as you want. I wasn't like
my rookie year at all. I'm hoping to get back to that- make some things happen.''
A good illustration of the kind of things Williams can make happen when his
shoulder is right was one of his games against the Colts his rookie year, in
which he had 2 FFs (one coughed up by Peyton Manning was returned for a TD by
teammate Keith Bullock), 1 FR, 1 sack and 4 tackles. In terms of measurables,
Tank is a physical specimen that has it all... not many SSs make Roy Williams
look like a potbellied slacker. Like Roy, his production has been compromised
by the fact that he is simultaneously the teams best run support AND cover safety,
and though he is LISTED at SS, he is often saddled with coverage responsibilities
and deployed more like a FS. Could be an elite blitzer from the safety position
if turned loose, like Leroy Butler or Brian Dawkins.
Bust: Kevin Carter (6'5" 290)... at one time Carter was one of
the highest rated DEs in the league. He has demonstrated remarkable durability
and resiliency, never missing a game in a career that has spanned nine seasons
(his first six with the Rams and the latest three with the Titans). The former
coveted sixth overall pick (1.06 '95) from Florida has had a somewhat checkered,
up and down career, with the highs admittedly being very high. He has had DD
sacks five of his nine seasons, most recently in '02 (10). Coming off of an
11 sack season in 2000 in which he wanted a break the bank contract (this followed
on the heels of probably his two best seasons... 12 sacks and 50 solos in '98
and 17 sacks and 31 solos in '99), St. Louis thought he had an excessive asking
price and inflated estimate of his value. Rather than trying to re-sign him,
they elected to get a return on their investment by dealing him to Tennessee
for a first round pick (1.29 '01, subsequently used on Ryan Pickett... the Rams
are seemingly underwater on that exchange). Never a big tackle-monger, he has
failed to crack 30 tackles as a Titan (though he has gotten to 29 with the consistency
of a metronome all three seasons), and barely got there with 31 his last two
seasons as a Ram. After a disappointing 2 sacks his initial season with Tennessee
in '01 and his rebound DD sack year the following season, he came up small with
a half dozen sacks in the '03 campaign, his lowest sack total (aside from the
forgettable first year with the Titans) since he was a rookie. Most importantly
to his immediate IDP prospects, with DT Robaire Smith (HOU) moving on in free
agency, Carter is being asked to slide inside. In the past three seasons only
two DTs have surpassed the DD sack threshold (the ex-Raider Rod Coleman with
11 in '02 and since retired Seahawk/Viking John Randle with 11 in '01)... nobody
did it last season. With elite DE Jevon (Freak 2.0) Kearse also being allowed
to walk, rookie DEs Travis LaBoy and Antwan Odom may not deflect much attention
away from Carter. He turns 31 on 9.21, and is hurtling towards the age when
players can crash and burn faster than a circa '70's Pinto crash test dummy.
BUFFALO BILLS
By Aaron Rudnicki
Sleeper: DE Chris Kelsay
Many scouts listed Chris as a potential 1st round pick last year, and some reports
indicated that the Bills would have considered taking him with their 1st round
pick if they didn't grab McGahee instead. Things worked out for them when Kelsay
slipped to round 2. He spent most of his rookie season learning behind starter
Ryan Denney, another former 2nd round pick. Denney has developed into a solid
run defender but he has shown very little as a pass rusher. Kelsay is more of
a complete DE, and is expected to compete with Denney for the starting job throughout
the preseason. The player he was most often compared to coming out of college
was Grant Wistrom, a guy who can defend the run and rush the passer and gives
all out effort on every play. Kelsay has a great motor, and he looked pretty
quick in the Bills preseason opener against the Broncos, where he registered
a sack of Jake Plummer and also stopped Quentin Griffin for a 4-yard loss. Denney
started the 1st game, but Kelsay will start game 2 against Tennessee. If he
continues to play well and put pressure on opposing QBs, DC Jerry Gray will
have to give him more playing time. If he can show enough in stopping the run,
he should have no problem winning that starting job, and playing alongside Aaron
Schobel, Pat Williams, and Sam Adams should provide him with plenty of quality
matchups to take advantage of. LDE aren't generally big fantasy producers, so
his upside is still somewhat limited for this season. However, Schobel is scheduled
to become a free agent in 2005, and if the Bills are unable to re-sign him,
then Kelsay would be an obvious choice to replace him at RDE. This gives Kelsay
added value in dynasty leagues, because the potential position switch could
significantly improve his numbers as early as next season.
Bust: FS Izell Reese
Reese was brought in last year to bring some stability to the FS position, but
he began the season backing up Pierson Prioleau. When Prioleau struggled early,
Reese got the starting nod and started 9 games before suffering a calf injury
that ended his season. In those 9 starts, Reese only managed to make 23 solo
tackles, and also failed to make any kind of big play with 0 INTs and only 1
PD. Reese has good height at 6'2" and decent range, but he has a slight
build and at only 195 lbs he doesn't bring much help in the way of run support.
Fortunately, the Bills are very strong up the middle with Pat Williams, Sam
Adams, London Fletcher, and Lawyer Milloy all being above average players at
their respective positions. Thus, Reese's main responsibility is deep coverage.
He is a steady player that doesn't make many mistakes, but he is too cautious
and doesn't make enough plays to be considered a fantasy option. In deeper leagues,
most starting safeties get drafted, but Reese is probably not worth a roster
spot. He appears to have held off Coy Wire with a strong training camp, but
undrafted free agent Rashad Baker has played very well and may push for playing
time at some point. Chances are that Troy Vincent will be moved to FS at some
point in the near future, so Reese is just holding the spot temporarily.
MIAMI DOLPHINS
By Aaron Rudnicki
Sleeper: SS Sammy Knight
While playing for the Saints in 2001 and 2002, Sammy Knight put together 2 of
the best fantasy seasons a DB has had in the past 4 years or so. Not only was
he a tackling machine with 80+ solo tackles in both seasons, but he also proved
to be a big time playmaker with 3 sacks, 11 INTs, 22 PD, 4 FF, and 6 FR in those
2 years. He signed a big free agent contract with the Dolphins last year and
was consistently one of the earliest DBs drafted. The change of scenery did
not help him at all, however, and he wound up seeing a pretty big drop in his
production across the board. His tackles dropped, and he finished with 0 sacks,
3 INTs, 6 PD, 2 FF, and 0 FR. Those numbers put him outside of the top-20 DBs
and now he is flying under the radar of many fantasy owners. The Dolphins as
a team gone through some changes that will likely have a positive effect on
Knight's numbers, which could make him a very nice value pick this year. The
loss of David Boston to a season ending injury and the unexpected retirement
of Ricky Williams has pretty much left the offense in shambles. Throw in an
inexperienced offensive coordinator and a completely rebuilt offensive line
and things are looking very ominous for the Dolphins offense in 2004. As a result,
the Dolphins defense should wind up being on the field for many more plays this
year, which leads to more opportunities for Knight to rack up numbers. The Dolphins
also cut ties with Pro Bowl FS Brock Marion this offseason, who put up numbers
that were very similar to Knight's. Marion is expected to be replaced by either
Arturo Freeman or Antwan Edwards, neither of whom would be considered an upgrade
at the position, and that decline at FS should provide additional tackle opportunities
for Knight to soak up. Lastly, the Dolphins have taken steps to upgrade themselves
at the CB position by signing Reggie Howard and drafting Will Poole. If the
CBs can do their job and lock down opposing WRs, that will force the QBs to
hold onto the ball longer and eventually throw up a bad pass for Knight to pick
off or perhaps check down to a play over the middle where Knight can get credit
for a tackle. He's not known for his speed, but is a big hitter with a knack
for making big plays, and at only 29 years old, he should be able to bounce
back to possibly a top-10 DB once again.
Bust: WLB Junior Seau
Junior actually had a decent season last year with 10 quality starts (6 or more
fantasy points) out of 15 games played. But, he's now 35 years old and likely
nearing the end of his career. He had some success getting to the QB with 3
sacks, but his numbers struggled in almost every other area: He failed to record
an INT for the first time since 1998, had his lowest number of passes defended
(3) since 1994, and failed to force a fumble for the first time since 1991 his
second year in the league. With the Dolphins offense expected to struggle now
that Ricky Williams has retired, the defense will likely be on the field for
more snaps this year, but can his body hold up? Seau has missed 4 games over
the past 2 seasons combined, and that number may continue to rise. Factor in
the loss of Ogunleye from the recent trade, and the Dolphins should have a lot
more trouble generating a consistent pass rush, which means more passes completed
by opposing QBs and likely fewer tackles from Junior. He'll probably still get
taken somewhat highly in many leagues based on name recognition alone, but Junior
has now had 2 down fantasy seasons in a row, and should not be counted on as
more than a LB5 and bye-week fill in at best.
NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS
By Aaron Rudnicki
Sleeper: CB Ty Law
Ty Law has established himself as one of the best CBs in the entire league.
In most circumstances, that would be a bad thing for his fantasy value as opposing
QBs would try to avoid throwing toward his side of the field. Law is somewhat
different, however, because he is not kept on one side of the field but rather
is allowed to change sides in order to stay with the opposing team's best WR.
By matching him up with the other team's best WR, he is much more likely to
be thrown at than other shutdown CBs that stay on the same side of the field.
Also, at 5'11", 200 lbs, Law is big enough to play physical and help out
in run support. He has been unhappy and making plenty of noise about his contract
situation this offseason, but the Pats have no intention of trading him and
Law has little choice but to play out his deal. Because of his unhappiness and
because he plays CB, he is dropping very far in most IDP drafts, but he has
been remarkably consistent over the past few years averaging roughly 60 solo
tackles and just under 4 INTs per year. He will highly motivated to go out and
prove his status as an elite player this year, and may even be able to improve
on the tremendous numbers he put up last year that saw him finish as a top-20
DB in many scoring systems. He is one of the few CBs that provide consistent
tackle production along with the potential for INTs and TDs that can lead to
huge scoring weeks.
Bust: LB Roosevelt Colvin
Colvin was a huge free agent signing for the Patriots last year, and was expected
to thrive in their new 3-4 defense. However, he blew up his hip on a play where
he received no contact, and the doctors said it looked like he had been through
a car wreck. The injury was very severe, and even though he has begun practicing
with the team, it is unlikely he'll be able to return to the form that helped
him rack up 22 sacks in 2 years with the Bears. His value is primarily as a
pass rusher, so chances are even if he's healthy the Pats would probably only
look to use him on certain passing downs to try and keep him as healthy as possible.
That would mean very few tackles, and would limit his fantasy value greatly.
The Pats won a Super Bowl without him, and 2 of their best defensive players
during that run were their OLBs Willie McGinest and Mike Vrabel. So, if he can
make a full recovery, Colvin will still have to battle those guys for playing
time. When you factor in the injury, and the chance that he'll only be a situational
player, Colvin is probably a player worth avoiding this year. At only 27 years
old, he should still have value in dynasty leagues, but he likely won't be 100%
until 2005.
NEW YORK JETS
By Aaron Rudnicki
Sleeper: SS Reggie Tongue
Reggie Tongue has had an up and down 8-year career in the NFL. He racked up
some great tackle numbers while playing for the Chiefs (averaged 80 solo tackles
from 1997 to 1999), and then signed a big free agent contract with the Seahawks.
He got off to a slow start with the Seahawks and made very little impact in
2000, but beginning in 2001, he showed a newfound ability as a playmaker and
averaged 4 INTs over the next 3 seasons. Despite his improvement in playmaking,
his tackling ability left a bit to be desired and the Seahawks decided to let
him leave as a free agent this offseason. The Jets, after having been spurned
by free agent John Lynch who signed with Denver, moved quickly to sign Tongue
to come in and be their new strong safety. He replaces Sam Garnes, who was a
bigger, stronger player but doesn't have the speed that Tongue brings to the
position. Tongue has good range and should become the playmaker of the Jets
defense. The Jets front 7 also looks to be very strong this year, with plenty
of guys that can put pressure on the QB, and that should give Tongue a lot of
INT opportunities. Tongue has been injured throughout training camp and appears
to be an afterthought in many IDP drafts, but he could wind up as a solid fantasy
starter and potentially finish as a top-30 DB if he can stay healthy.
*NOTE: This is, of course, contingent on Reggie Tongue holding off Erik
Coleman for the starting job.
Bust: Shaun Ellis
Shaun Ellis had a breakthrough season last year with 12.5 sacks and an invite
to the Pro Bowl. A closer look at his numbers, however, reveals that he slowed
down a lot in the second half of the season (only 20 solo tackles and 3 sacks
in games 9 through 16). In fact, he got most of his sacks while John Abraham
was healthy and playing opposite him on the defensive line. Once Abraham went
down, teams began sliding their pass protection over to Ellis' side and he struggled
to make the same type of impact. This year, Abraham will be healthy, so that
is good news for Ellis, but the Jets plan to use more 3-4 fronts in their defensive
game plans. As most IDP owners know, the 3-4 LDE isn't generally a great fantasy
option, as they have more responsibility in stopping the run and don't get as
much freedom to rush the passer. Ellis is a quality player who was happy to
finally settle in at DE after being moved around a lot earlier in his career,
but it will be difficult for him to match the numbers he put up last season.
He is entering a contract year, but the Jets apparently are close to locking
him up to a long-term deal before the season even begins, so the lure of a big
payday in 2005 may not even serve as a motivator for him.
BALTIMORE RAVENS
By Aaron Rudnicki
Sleeper: LB Edgerton Hartwell
Edgerton Hartwell started off his college career at the University of Wisconsin
but transferred to Western Illinois where he was a big-time playmaker. Despite
only playing 3 seasons, he set the school career record for tackles and was
named the NCAA 1-AA Defensive Player of the Year in 2000. Hartwell was drafted
to backup Ray Lewis, and then went on to perform like a top-10 LB in 2002 after
Ray Lewis got injured. Last year, with Lewis healthy, Hartwell just managed
to crack the top-50. Obviously, a healthy Ray Lewis will rack up most of the
tackles and limit his upside, but there still might be enough opportunities
leftover for Hartwell to emerge as a consistent fantasy starter. A quick look
at the numbers put up by both ILBs with the Houston Texans provides an idea
of how two ILB can both be productive at the same time while playing in a 3-4
defense. The Ravens switched to a 3-4 base last year, and Hartwell may have
simply needed some time to adjust. He was a restricted free agent this year
and signed just a 1-year extension with the Ravens, so he will be playing for
a big free agent contract next summer. At only 26 years old, he should be entering
the prime of his career and it would be perfectly reasonable to expect some
improvement on last year's numbers. His performance in the last game of 2003
against the Steelers (9 solos, 3 assists, 1.5 sacks) provides a glimpse of what
he is capable of. He should have added value in dynasty leagues, because of
his youth and the fact that he is a pending free agent and could wind up apart
from Ray Lewis as a starting MLB next year.
Bust: LB Terrell Suggs
Suggs won the defensive rookie of the year award last year and was a pass rushing
phenom with 12 sacks in limited playing time, but he only racked up 19 solo
tackles in 16 games played. Last year, Adalius Thomas would normally start ahead
of him, and then be moved to DE on passing downs so Suggs could get in the game.
This year, Thomas is filling in for Peter Boulware at the opposite OLB spot
and Suggs is playing all 3 downs. Based on the ROY award and the increase in
playing time, Suggs is bound to go early in a lot of IDP drafts. But, with Ray
Lewis and Hartwell lining up at ILB, there aren't going to be a whole lot of
tackles left over. Additionally, Suggs is still making the adjustment from playing
DE in college to playing OLB in the pros. Peter Boulware is a similar type of
player to Suggs in that they are both converted DEs who are known primarily
as pass rushers. A look at Boulware's career numbers shows several double digit
sack seasons but only 1 season where he topped 50 solo tackles. Unless your
league awards an unusually high number of points for sacks, those types of players
are not going to be very useful. Tackles are the most important fantasy stat
for IDPs, and Suggs simply won't make enough tackles to be consistent from week
to week, no matter how many sacks he is able to rack up.
CLEVELAND BROWNS
By Aaron Rudnicki
Sleeper: LB Warrick Holdman
The Browns decision last year to go with 3 2nd-year players at LB didn't really
work out all that well for them. Andra Davis put up great numbers at MLB, but
the OLBs didn't make enough plays to help get the defense off the field. This
year, the Browns have added a reliable and proven veteran in Warrick Holdman,
and have also been singing the praises of last year's 2nd round pick Chaun Thompson.
Thompson brings a great size/speed ratio to the position, but he is still very
raw and inexperienced. As the most experienced LB on the team, Holdman seems
an obvious sleeper candidate. He was a dominant player in 2001 in Chicago, where
he racked up more tackles than Urlacher and also showed some playmaking ability
with 1.5 sacks, 1 INT, and 3 FF. The Bears signed him to a big contract after
that season, but ended up releasing him this offseason after injuries forced
him to miss 15 games over the past 2 seasons. He should be healthy to start
the season, and the Browns defense will likely continue to struggle getting
off the field again, which means plenty of snaps for whoever winds up starting
at WLB. Although Holdman probably won't be one of the fastest Browns LBs, he
makes up for it with very solid tackling, good anticipation, and the ability
to shed blocks and make a play. By virtue of his experience, Holdman should
bring some much needed stability and consistency to the Browns LB corps, and
he could pay off nicely for fantasy owners willing to take a chance.
Bust: SS Robert Griffith
Robert Griffith has been a big disappointment in Cleveland after signing a big
free agent contract in 2002. He was expected to solidify the secondary and become
a leader on the defense, but he misses far too many tackles and at 34 years
old, probably doesn't have a whole lot left in the tank. The team traded up
into the 2nd round to draft safety Sean Jones, who was expected to push Griffith
and FS Earl Little for playing time, but he tore his ACL earlier this offseason.
Now, it appears that former 6th round pick Michael Jameson is having a very
strong preseason and is pushing Griffith for playing time. Jameson is almost
10 years younger than Griffith, has good range, and is a little bit bigger.
Griffith's main advantage at this point is experience, but Butch Davis didn't
hesitate to replace an experienced LB group last year with 3 unproven players.
Griffith is still listed as the starter, but he'll need to play better than
he did in 2003 if he wants to hold onto his job. Griffith had about 8 quality
starts (6 fantasy points or more) out of 16 games played last season, but he
also missed 10 games from 2001 to 2002 and could be an injury risk at this point
in his career as well. The Browns run defense was abysmal last year, and Griffith
took a lot of blame for Jamal Lewis' monster games. He'll likely survive the
season since the Browns have little experience behind him, but he looks to be
on his last legs and may be out of the league as early as 2005.
CINCINNATI BENGALS
By Aaron Rudnicki
Sleeper: LB Nate Webster
Nate Webster came from the same school that gave us Mike Barrow, Ray Lewis,
Dan Morgan, and Jonathan Vilma. That's an impressive lineage of MLBs, as most
of those guys were drafted in the 1st round. Webster entered the draft after
his junior season and was taken in the 3rd round by Tampa Bay. During his 4
years in Tampa, he never really got a great chance to contribute much as he's
been stuck behind players like Derrick Brooks, Jamie Duncan, and Shelton Quarles.
But, he did get a chance to start 5 games in 2003 when Quarles was out with
an injury. He put up solid tackle numbers in 4 out of those 5 games and apparently
showed enough for the Bengals - who signed him to a 5-year contract in March
- to think he can make a difference for their defense. Webster is a tenacious
defender who is known for giving his all on every single play. He is undersized
compared to many MLBs around the league at 6', 235 lbs, but he plays bigger
than that and makes up for it with great range. Webster is a very good run defender
who should be a better fit at MLB than Kevin Hardy (moved back to SLB), and
could blossom in Marvin Lewis' scheme. Consider this: When they were both in
college at Miami, Webster was good enough to keep Dan Morgan at WLB. He may
need some time to adjust and get comfortable, but he has enough talent to emerge
as a solid fantasy LB this year.
Bust: DE Justin Smith
Justin Smith was taken with the #4 overall selection in the draft - right ahead
of LaDainian Tomlinson and Richard Seymour. He looked like a future star after
his rookie season when he put up 8.5 sacks as well as a couple INTs In 2002,
he improved his play against the run and was able to increase his number of
solo tackles to 48 and also added a couple FFs, but his sack numbers took a
slight drop. He then followed that up with a mediocre season in 2003 that saw
almost all of his numbers drop. For a player taken that high in the draft, he
should be dominating at this point in his career, yet he seems to be regressing.
Instead of being an impact DE, he just looks average. Fortunately for him, the
Bengals have very little depth at DE so he isn't likely to lose his job anytime
soon. But, he tends to be overvalued in IDP leagues because of his top-5 draft
status, which gives people the impression that he has a ton of upside. After
three years in the league, however, it's hard to imagine him all of a sudden
becoming the impact player everyone expects him to be.
PITTSBURGH STEELERS
By Aaron Rudnicki
Sleeper: DB Troy Polamalu
The Steelers wanted Polamalu bad last year, and ended up giving up their 3rd
and 6th round picks to move up in the 1st round and make sure they got him.
He got off to a slow start last year in training camp and wasn't able to supplant
Mike Logan as the starter at SS, but he contributed on special teams and started
to get more playing time late in the year. The team is committed to him, and
he will be relied on heavily to upgrade a Steeler defense that has been slipping
in recent years. Polamalu is an intimidating presence in the secondary who will
definitely lay some highlight reel hits on people this season. He doesn't have
great size at only 5'10", 213 lbs, but he is blessed with great range and
solid instincts. Polamalu is solid in coverage but he's not a ballhawk so he
isn't likely to put up a bunch of INTs With LeBeau back in town as the Steelers
defensive coordinator, you can expect plenty of blitzing from the LBs, which
means that Polamalu will often be used as an extra LB in run support. Polamalu
also times his blitzes well and racked up 2 sacks in his final 4 games last
year, so expect a handful of sacks from him this year as well. Very few safeties
have been drafted as high as #16 overall, and based on that factor alone he
has the potential to emerge as an elite fantasy DB. Many owners have written
him off because he didn't make a big impact right away, which means he can be
had much later in drafts this year than he was last year when the hype machine
was in full force. He represents great value after the top-20 or so DBs have
gone and has a chance to outperform his draft position by a very wide margin.
Bust: LB Joey Porter
Joey Porter had a huge season in 2002 that saw him finish as a top-10 LB in
many fantasy scoring systems. However, that year has the markings of a career
year that is not likely to be repeated again. First, his solo tackle total of
61 is not very impressive for a LB, and it was his highest total by far in 4
years as a starter. Second, he wound up with 4 INTs in that single season, despite
having only 1 INT in his 4 other seasons combined. Third, he added 10 PD despite
never breaking 4 in any other season. Then, despite averaging over 9 sacks from
2000-2002, he saw his sack total drop to 5 last year, although in fairness his
2003 season did get off to a bad start when he suffered a gunshot wound during
the preseason that forced him to miss 2 games. However, at this point in his
career, it appears as though we have a pretty good idea of what his numbers
will look like from year to year. Expect roughly 50-60 solo tackles, and perhaps
10 sacks, but that is barely enough to make him a starter in most IDP leagues.
Additionally, recent reports have suggested that Kendrell Bell is being included
in the nickel package at LB after having dropped roughly 15 lbs and gaining
a greater understanding of the defense. Porter will likely be used at DE on
passing downs, but now that Jason Gildon has been replaced by untested Clark
Haggans, opposing teams may be able to focus their blocking schemes on Porter
more than they could in the past. The return of LeBeau may cause some people
to overrate Porter this year, because even though his sack total might increase,
it is unlikely that his tackles will improve enough to make him very valuable.
|
|